an illustration of a devil writing the blog article on a wall, meant to reference the art of magic the gathering card indomnible creativity.

Devils’ Playground: Summarizing the Modern Season – Love Letters

Love Letters is a new segment of the Pandemonium blog where staff write essays about books, games, and adjacent topics that they're passionate about. This time around we have Ryan breaking down this past season of Modern in Magic the Gathering, and offering some insights into the future of the format.

+++++

 

Hello, everyone! I’m Ryan, an employee here at Pandi and an avid fan of the trading card game Magic: The Gathering (MTG). A little bit about my journey in this amazing game before we kick off the topic I’d like to discuss today.


Scroll of Origins (SoK)


I first encountered MTG in 2017; the Speed vs. Cunning starter decks were oh-so-conspicuously positioned behind my physics tutor’s head on a shelf at Barnes & Noble. As a distractible teenager, I was enamored with the beautifully illustrated Orc and Wizard, who, in that little box, seemed to embody the duality of power through their themes. One was big and brawny—a fierce general leading an equally savage army—and the other, grand in a different sense, seemed to weave the very fabric of reality with an arcane touch. Put plainly, I was mesmerized. Kudos to Ryan Alexander Lee, by the way, for a fantastic job on the two featured cards: Zurgo Helmsmasher and Arcanis the Omnipotent. Noticing that I wasn't focused on whatever I was supposed to be focused on, however, my tutor looked over his shoulder to see what I’d been looking at. He saw the two decks, then faced me again, an eyebrow raised. He said something then that has, and I imagine will, continue to inhibit my ability to purchase property. He said, “Finish this problem, and if you get it correct, I will teach you how to play Magic.” To this day, I have never been so enthusiastic about physics. 

 

MAGIC THE GATHERING CARD, ARCANIS THE OMNIPOTENT

MAGIC THE GATHERING CARD ZURGO HELMSMASHER


And thus began my journey into this wonderful hobby. What began as curiosity quickly became an obsession, and a year later, with the release of Dominaria, I bought my first booster box. Since then, my MTG experiences have largely focused on two formats: Commander and my favorite, Modern (though I have dabbled in many others). And thus begins my little(-ish) topic for the day: Modern. 


As Standard takes its seasonal precedence and the sun sets on Modern, I would like to take a quick look back and examine how this modern season played out. I want to look at the many metagame shifts we experienced, including exciting evolutions in deck archetypes, and where the format stands as we prepare for the wild-west Modern format that always seems to take over when people no longer play to “qualify” but instead play the old favs and wild brews. 


Glorious Purpose (MSC)


First, we should probably define what the Modern format is. Simply put, Modern is a competitive, eternal, constructed 60-card/15-card sideboard 1 vs. 1 format that allows all main-set cards printed with the Modern MTG card frame (essentially 2003 and onward). The format also allows all cards printed in Modern Horizons sets and The Lord of the Rings set as well. Of the legal cards, 52 are banned. Simple right? Gameplay-wise, it is defined by how versatile each deck can be with incredibly powerful (arguably broken) draws and, when disrupted, equally powerful, though slower, back-up plans. It offers a large swath of efficient answers and an equally vast set of viable strategies. It has also been known to cost a pretty penny. But I digress. 


This past Modern RCQ season ran for 17 weeks, from April 4th of 2026 to August 2nd of 2026, and the Regional Championship season ran from early September up until early November. The season featured one Pro Tour: “Pro Tour: Marvel Superheroes” with a top 8 draft (biggest sad face—though good for the drafters, I suppose) and a large swath of other events, including regional championships and several more spotlight series, all of which could qualify you for the next modern Pro Tour in 2027. 

 

magic the gathering card: phlage, titan of fire's fury


Crumbling Colossus (M12)


The first big shakeup this season occurred before the season even began. As Burn players cried hopeless tears and Amulet Titan pilots practiced their convoluted combo lines while reviewing their 80-page Google Doc primer, the rest of us prepared to play, or beat, Boros (RW) Energy. Then everything changed when the overlords of modern (WOTC…I guess?) attacked. Suddenly, on May 18th, Phlage, Titan of Fire’s Fury, and Lotus Field were banned. Cards off the banlist included Umizawa’s Jitte, which was… negligible, and Violent Outburst? My immediate reaction: Temur Rhynos is back! (Tldr: it wasn’t). Still, players remained apprehensive about Boros’ supposed continued dominance in the metagame and, arguably, one of the most frustrating play patterns returning: an instant-speed cascade into living end, with force of negation back up. How these bans played out, however, was quite interesting. 


Boros Energy has been called, or was called before the ban, the new Jund of post-Horizon sets. The primary difference is that while Jund was cool, Boros was not (kidding, sorry to all the Boros enjoyers out there). The real difference was that while Jund tried to play a game of two-for-ones, seeking out incremental advantage over a grindy game by two-for-oneing your opponent, Boros Energy played a game of 1, 2, there are now thirty cats, and you die. The entire deck pre-ban was focused on high-synergy 2-card packages that, when paired together, could take over the game: Guide of Souls + Ocelot Pride, Ajani Nacotl Parriah + Goblin Bombardment, Phlage + Arena of Glory. The sweep of powerful 1-drop cards, plus the ability to deploy an 18-point life swing from the graveyard on turn 4 (escape Phlage with haste, ETB trigger deal 3 & gain 3, attack trigger deal 3 & gain 3, connect for 6 damage) after a board wipe, made the deck incredibly resilient and tough to play against. Phlage getting the axe, however, forced Boros to pivot to a more aggressive shell. With its late-game threat banned, pilots considered the next-best threat for the Phlage slot. And the new Boros Energy deck would make its debut at Pro Tour: Marvel Superheroes. 

 

magic the gathering card: kappa cannoneer


But there was another deck at this Pro Tour with a target on its back: Izzit (RU) affinity. Affinity is an inherently broken mechanic that sacrifices card quality to quickly deploy lethal threats as early as turn 1—the threat in question: Kappa Canonneer. In day 1 of Pro Tour: Edge of Eternities (2025), Japanese pro player Shuhei Nakamura piloted an early version of this deck to an undefeated record, and despite not being able to top 8, Izzit affinity was on the map. Nearly a year later, the deck had established itself in the metagame and proven its power. 


Unexpected Results (GTC)


As the pros finished drafting and I ignored friends telling me it was time to play DND, the metagame numbers for Pro Tour: Marvel Superheroes were revealed. The most popular decks, and the decks to beat, were, to no one's surprise, Boros Energy, with a respectable but not nearly as prominent 12.7% metagame share, and Izzit affinity, also at 12.7%. Despite this, the decks performed poorly: Boros had a 45% win rate in the field, and Izzit had a 46.2% win rate. It seems the bans did their job, and people came prepared to face both the once-giant and the rising star. 


Speaking of bans, what about Temur (URG) Living End and Amulet Titan? You might ask if you are at all able to follow this. To that I say, “Who cares! Did you see Fight Rigging Trudge? That's an Aspiring Spike deck! I watch that guy on the internet sometimes.” If you're at all interested in modern, I do recommend visiting his channel. He brews some fun—not always good—decks and will appear later in this blog if I have the word count to spare. 


Indeed, a brand-new deck within the Eldrazi archetype dominated this Pro Tour. While other teams focused on proven decks and beating them (yes, there are teams in Magic: The Gathering. Yes, it is also a 1 vs 1 format. No, I do not know how that works), nine players, mostly from Team Moriyama Japan, decided to bring Fight Rigging Trudge to the event. And they freakin knocked it out of the park. The deck focuses on utilizing the powerful combo between the new-at-the-time card Slumbering Trudge, a 1-mana 6/6 from Secrets of Strixhaven that enters tapped with three stun counters, and Fight Rigging, a three-mana enchantment with Hideaway 5 (look at the top 5 cards; exile one of them face down). The more modern-familiar of you might know what happens next, but if you don't, please allow me the courtesy of explaining. For you see, Fight Rigging has other text: at the beginning of combat, put a +1/+1 counter on a creature you control; then, if you control a creature with power 7 or greater, you may cast the exiled card without paying its mana cost. So, on turn 1, play a Trudge; then, on turn 2, play Fight Rigging (why not turn 3? Isn’t it 3 mana? Yes, but other cards let you play it on turn 2), exile a big Eldrazi, go to combat, put a counter on the Trudge, making its power 7… I think you see where this is going. EMRAKUL, THE PROMISED END! 

 

magic the gathering card: emrakul, the promised end


Despite Fight Rigging Trudge's astounding win rate at this particular pro tour—65.4% (53W-28L recorded across 9 pilots)—the deck hasn't maintained a high metagame share or put up any notable results since (right after I built it too!). I imagine this is for several key reasons. First, the deck struggles against highly interactive decks that stop your combo. Cards like Solitude, Fatal Push, Force of Negation, and Vexing Bauble, to name a few, are cheap, commonly played, and efficient ways to neuter Trudge’s faster opening hands. The deck is also luck-based; Fight Rigging exiles only one card from the top five of your deck, and though the odds of finding a late-game bomb are high, you can low-roll and potentially lose an otherwise easy win. 


To make matters worse, your backup plan of ramping into Emrakul is slower to execute than other decks in the metagame. While Fanatic of Rhonas + Trudge can make a bunch of green mana as early as turn 3, both are creature permanents and relatively easy to answer when your opponent is prepared. Third, it struggles against aggressive decks that can pressure your life total and punish your slower draws, or other combo decks that completely ignore you. The biggest factor hindering the deck’s success, however, is that people are prepared for it now. In the right midrangy metagame, perhaps this deck may be worth returning to, but for now it seems to lack key tools that might increase its match percentage.


Ripples of Potential (EOC)



After Pro Tour: Marvel Superheroes, Modern saw some crazy metagame shifts, and for a while, it felt as if every week featured a new top dog. First it was Esper (WUB) Goryo’s Vengeance (a Psychic frog/Riddler Ephemerate deck that focuses on reanimating Atraxa). Then it was Izzet (R/U) Prowess (An aggro deck that plays six spells in a turn to kill you with an aggravating hasty bird). Then it was Esper (WUB) Blink/Phelia (similar to Goryo’s, just midrange-y and without the busted stuff). We also got to see some other powerful archetypes work their way up the ladder. Golgari (GB) Devoted Druid rose and fell; Dimir (UB) Flash piloted by Aspiring Spike to a top 8 finish at Spotlight Dallas (he has a fantastic video summarizing his experience, and the Win and In match against Tron was awesome); Domain (WUBRG) Zoo perpetually lingered in the top ten. But then, everyone stared in awe and fear as one deck rose above the rest. And that deck was…(WUBURG) Creativity. 


 

Just kidding. I wish it were true, though; I love creativity. 


The new deck to beat was Eldrazi Broodscale. In a nutshell, Eldrazi Broodscale is the epitome of a modern deck. The deck can be incredibly fast, with a quick infinite mana combo and a swath of consistency pieces to help you find it, but is also quite resilient. At its core, the deck is a ramp deck with access to the best high-mana colorless threats in the format, allowing you to go over the top of other midrange strategies. Additionally, like any good Modern deck, it can interact surprisingly well. With access to Kozilek’s Command (called by many the best card in Modern) and some backbreaking artifacts, the deck has not only a proactive game plan but also the ability to pivot when it needs to. Many of these artifacts (Vexing Bauble, Soul-Guide Lantern, and sometimes Pithing Needle or Haywire Mite) can be tutored with Urza’s Saga’s Chapter Three ability as well, meaning they take up very little deck space and function as a toolbox that the Broodscale player can use to tackle a vast amount of situations. 


magic the gathering card: basking broodscale

 

In sum, the deck is good.


At the height of its popularity, Eldrazi Broodscale reached a 22% metagame share. It also took down two Regional Championships: RC Baltimore (in the hands of Pete Ingram) and RC Ghent (in the hands of Alexander Rosdahl), and averaged a 55% win rate across multiple big tournaments this season. 


But again, Modern is a very complex format, and whenever any deck rises in metagame percentage, others will adjust. For months, Broodscale sat at the top; its matchup spread was generally favorable, with marginal but notable advantages over many of the other best decks. Then, as is often the case, the deck's foil was discovered. Toward the end of the season, in early October, one deck emerged seemingly out of nowhere to beat the titan of this Modern Season. 


Foil (PCY)


On October 3rd, a new strategy within the control archetype emerged to deal with Broodscale. By cutting traditional control pieces like Counterspell that are pretty bad against Eldrazi cast triggers, this Azorius (W/U) deck dubbed “Azorius Chant” plays six or seven maindeck silence effects and a Narset + Day’s Undoing combo that leaves your opponent with no cards in hand, no hope, and no fun to be had. The deck boasted a 59.2% win rate across five RCs and took down two of them: Regional Championship Ottawa in the hands of Kaya Cregg and Regional Championship Los Angeles in the hands of Nate Green. Since then, the deck continues to perform well and has proved to be a silver bullet against Broodscale. 

 

magic the gathering card: orim's chant


Several less popular decks made big impressions at some of those more recent Regional Championships (Ghent, LA, Ottawa, Japan) as well. Some of those decks were revitalized by new cards from Reality Fracture, while others were straight up invented around these new cards. Out of these, no deck is performing as well as Rakdos (B/R) Agro/Delirium. Piloted by Hall of Famer Shuhei Nakamura to a 5th place finish at Regional Championship Japan, the deck runs 4 copies of Dark Matter Manipulator to serve as an early threat and powerful self-mill card to help fuel our graveyard-centric game plan. The card can single-handedly turn on delirium if we’re lucky, and digs for Detective's Phoenix, a powerful creature that we can cast from the graveyard as an aura spell for big bursts of hasty damage. Since the deck's inception and first RC, many other pilots have brought the deck to their own tournaments and have done well with it. Though it has not yet won anything of note, it has a slightly favorable matchup into Broodscale and boasts a win percentage of between 56-58% at the most recent RCs. 


Glimpse The Future (M14)


Though there is still so much to talk about and so many decks that have yet to be featured in my little blog post, I wish now to look forward. Not to the metagame that was, but to the metagame that is and the one that could be. But mostly, I wish to talk very briefly about some recent decks that have caught my attention and decks I might be testing in the off-season.

 

magic the gathering card: chandra, chill of compliance


First on the list: Azorius Miracles. Miracles is an old control archetype that has a history in Modern and even Legacy, I think…don’t quote me on that. Its primary objective is to draw and cast cards like Terminus and Temporal Mastery, allowing for a significant mana deduction on an otherwise uncastable card in a constructed format. Azorius Miracles in modern now has access to Chandra, Chill of Compliance a three-mana walker that, when paired with Enhanced Surveillance, can help draw interaction or stack miracles on top of your deck.


Second on the list: This Rakdos Agro deck is so fun to play, and several variants do exist. Some out there are playing higher quantities of efficient removal like Flare of Malice to get rid of pesky planeswalkers and high mana value creatures alike, while others play Troll of Khazad-Dum and prioritize other removal spells like Unholy Heat. I think I prefer the former over the latter. It’s nice to have something to do when the opponent goes for a chant in your upkeep. 

 

magic the gathering card: way of the pyromancer


Okay, last deck before I offer up my closing thoughts. Indomitable Creativity, especially the 5-color version, has received some new toys from Reality Fracture. Way of the Paradox + Wrenn and Six has proven to be a powerful synergy, taking Sidney Mayor (Napoleon 1 on the Creativity Discord) to a top-32 finish with a 10-3-1 record at RC Ghent. I’ve been on creativity since MH2, and this was awesome to see. I’ve also been iterating on the archetype and have opted for a Jeskai version that uses the power of Orim’s Chant and Teferi, Time Raveler to provide windows to cast my clunky finisher spell. A fantastic new addition to that deck has been Way of the Pyromancer: a proactive spell that Empowers Jace 2 and lets all planeswalkers +1: add a red mana. Playing it on turn two allows you to uptick the Jace token and cast Galvanic Discharge, removing an opponent’s 1- or 2-drop. It’s felt decent so far, and I’m excited to continue working on it for the next RCQ season.


Closing Statment (STX)


Modern is a crazy format that allows a host of viable strategies. Decks are powerful, and interaction is key. The metagame churns at a consistent rate (barring any additional MH sets) and games can be fast but can also become quite grindy, especially when people are playing around certain cards. All the dynamics of a healthy metagame exist within this format, and no two games ever play out exactly the same way. For that reason, and the play patterns that belong solely to Modern, this format has my heart. 


I recently had a birthday, and for that birthday, I printed off a collection of proxied Modern decks. I invited my commander group over and “forced” them to play a three-round Swiss tournament where every player played one of the proxied decks. Only two of the seven had ever played modern, mind you, and only one of them semi-seriously (she plays neobrand, and though it's a cool deck, it sucks to test against). Everyone had a great time, and we plan to do it again when we next meet. I encourage you, if you have a commander group or draft group, to do something similar. Print some 60-card competitive decks: Legacy, Standard, Pauper, or Modern, whatever the format might be, and give it a shot. You might just discover another beautiful facet of the 30+ year card game MTG.



Cheers, and thank you for reading.

Always bolt the bird!

 

+++++


Ryan Ferguson has been a member of the Pandemonium Team since May of 26. He’s been playing TCGs since 2017 and has been covered in games since his father “forced” him to play D&D at the ripe old age of 7. In addition to helping buy and sort cards for the store, Ryan can be seen in the wild running the register, helping players build decks, or basking in a hot cup of joe. While he doesn’t fit in the cup anymore, it reminds him of simpler times. His favorite beverage is currently Celsius (Peach Vibe Edition).

Back to blog